The retirement comparison
Both approaches start with the same corporate assets and new retained earnings, and provide $250,000 of annual net retirement spending. The IRP combines $100,000 of policy-backed borrowing with $150,000 net from investments; the portfolio-only approach provides the full $250,000 net from investments. The IRP allocates $50,000 a year to a participating whole life policy and $50,000 to investments for 20 years. The alternative invests the full $100,000 annually. New retained earnings stop at retirement.
| Modeled outcome | Portfolio + IRP | Portfolio only |
|---|
| Opening corporate portfolio | $1,000,000 | $1,000,000 |
|---|
| New retained earnings over 20 years | $2,000,000 | $2,000,000 |
|---|
| Total policy contributions | $1,000,000 | — |
|---|
| Annual retirement spending | $250,000 | $250,000 |
|---|
| Cumulative retirement cash flow | $6,250,000 | $6,250,000 |
|---|
| Investment portfolio at retirement | $5.06M | $6.99M |
|---|
| Investment portfolio at death | $10.33M | $11.82M |
|---|
| Net estate value | $9.13M | $8.15M |
|---|
| Added net estate value | $974,135 | — |
|---|
| Whole-plan IRR | 5.14% | 4.99% |
|---|
The insurance and borrowing
| Policy death benefit | $6,911,477 |
|---|
| Policy CDA credit | $6,911,477 |
|---|
| Outstanding personal loan at death | $5,011,345 |
|---|
| Insurance proceeds remaining after loan repayment | $1,900,132 |
|---|
| Cumulative guarantee fees paid to the corporation | $527,383 |
|---|
The added estate value compares the entire plan after corporate investment taxes, refundable tax recovery, personal distributions, loan repayment, and the assumed post-mortem planning. It is not simply the death benefit less the loan. Cash value is not added to the death benefit.
The investment return needed to match
The portfolio-only approach would need an approximately 7.17% annual return, net of investment fees and before tax, to provide the same retirement spending and match the IRP estate value. This scales the return assumptions proportionately while keeping the same portfolio mix. The baseline weighted return is 7.00% on that basis.
The physician and timeline
Female, age 45, non-smoker, Ontario resident. Twenty beginning-of-year contributions of $50,000 fund the policy. Borrowing begins at age 65, at the start of policy year 21, with 25 annual $100,000 advances. Death is modeled at age 90, at the end of policy year 45. The illustration labels its annual rows by age at year-end.
The investment assumptions
60% equities with 8% capital appreciation, 20% Canadian eligible-dividend investments returning 6%, and 20% fixed income earning 5% interest; annual rebalancing. Returns are net of fees and before tax. Equity gains are realized on sales and rebalancing; remaining gains are realized at death. The opening $1 million portfolio is assumed to have a $1 million tax cost, with $50,000 non-eligible RDTOH and zero eligible RDTOH, CDA, and GRIP. Share ACB and paid-up capital are each $1. These are hypothetical opening balances.
How IRR is measured
Whole-plan IRR includes the opening $1 million corporate portfolio, $100,000 of new retained earnings at the beginning of each of 20 years, $250,000 annual retirement cash flow from ages 65 through 89, and the net estate at age 90. Policy premiums are included within retained earnings and are not counted twice. This is a combined corporate-capital-to-personal-benefit measure, not the policy's stand-alone IRR.
Borrowing and the guarantee fee
The shareholder borrows personally at 5%, with interest capitalized. Interest and the guarantee fee are not deducted for personal spending. A fee of 1% of each year-end outstanding loan is paid by the shareholder to the corporation. Portfolio distributions fund the fee in addition to $150,000 net for spending. Together with $100,000 of policy-backed borrowing, this leaves $250,000 available for spending. The corporation retains the fee after an assumed 26.5% general corporate income tax. The fee itself is not a tax; its amount and tax treatment require professional review and lender documentation.
The illustrated loan reaches 87.12% of cash value at age 90, within the illustration's 90% lending limit. Future lending, rates, dividends, and collateral requirements can change. Borrowing can reduce the estate and may require additional collateral or loan repayment.
Taxes and the estate
Fixed 2026 Ontario top-rate assumptions: 50.17% corporate investment-income tax, 38.33% Part IV tax on eligible dividends, 50% capital-gains inclusion, 39.34% personal eligible-dividend tax, and 47.74% non-eligible-dividend tax. The model tracks CDA, GRIP, eligible and non-eligible RDTOH, and dividend refunds. Insurance proceeds create CDA credit after policy ACB, which is zero at the modeled death.
A coordinated full share redemption and section 164(6) loss carryback within the first three taxation years of a graduated rate estate is assumed. The section 112(3.2) stop-loss rules are applied; no residual share capital-gains tax arises in this modeled comparison. Share value includes policy cash surrender value and recoverable tax balances, while the personal bank loan is repaid separately. No pipeline, estate freeze, or LCGE is assumed. Eligibility, valuation, elections, and timing require tax and legal advice.
How the fee changes the result
Fee sensitivity only; a lower fee is not assumed to be appropriate for a particular arrangement.| Annual guarantee fee | Cumulative fees | Added estate value |
|---|
| 0% | $0 | $1,439,217 |
|---|
| 0.5% | $263,691 | $1,208,547 |
|---|
| 1% | $527,383 | $974,135 |
|---|
A modeled example, not a forecast or guarantee. Policy values use the supplied current dividend-scale illustration, which includes a term rider during the funding period. The comparison does not model inflation, market volatility, future tax changes, or every possible borrowing structure. Actual outcomes depend on policy performance, lending terms, fee treatment, and coordinated tax planning.
Tax references: share valuation at death, stop-loss rules, and estate loss carryback.